Yeah, I’m back on this again and ignoring that review that I’ll be posting probably either later tonight or sometime tomorrow. Here’s the thing, I’ve been a fan of Barbara Gordon since back in the nineties with Batman the Animated Series when I had no clue that the comics were any different. Back then, I had no idea that The Killing Joke had happened or that there was a second Batgirl. This was the character that I wanted to grow up to be. She was like Velma but with more attitude and she got to work with Batman.
Fast forward to sometime during high school and I’ve heard of The Killing Joke but not read it. I’ve heard that there was a second Batgirl and that she was rather poorly delt with for a chunk of her run in the cape. But I hadn’t really started reading comics yet. The Sandman, sure but that was because the school library had it in trade paperbacks and I had free time while being a library aide. It was around this time that I started to get more interested in comics as a whole, so I’d started reading up on DC’s super heroes to see who I wanted to focus on.
Fast forward again to around February. Holy cow there’s going to be a Batwoman monthly comic! Issue #0 is coming out and The Question is going to be in Birds of Prey! I was practically dancing in my seat with this one. Plus I was trying to keep up with the Odyssy of Wonder Woman arc of Wonder Woman because I wanted to see how they changed the character. And follow it through to Flashpoint and my various rants on that, it’s really one of the things that sticks out at me as a forced money grab even now. But I’ve finally got that Batwoman ongoing as part of my draw list, and Birds of Prey is still pretty cool even without Lady Blackhawk or Huntress.
It’s kind of itchy though, reading Batgirl and seeing Barbara go from tough leadery Oracle to a Batgirl so full of self doubt that I almost expect that the villain is going to wind up doing himself in rather than her winning.This is where I get to the meat of my ramble, don’t worry the rest was just back story. Now, not all of the sources agree, but apparently Babs was Oracle sometime during those three years post-Flashpoint. Why isn’t she still? I’m basing this mostly on the character I was reading back in Birds of Prey but it’s hard to see her giving up the autonomy of being a hero on her own to step back under the Batmantle. Out of the chair she’s still the same character, or at least she should be. Post-Flashpoint Batgirl seems to assume a Barbara who never quit being Batgirl prior to The Killing Joke, one who would go back to that after having been Oracle.
This is a character who questioned her reasons for crime fighting right up through the eighties when she quit and was then shot in the spine for being related to Batman’s supporting cast. Except it isn’t anymore, maybe. What was DCnU Barbara Gordon like before the Joker shot her? Was she Silver Age Batgirl with her Batpurse and day job as a librarian? Was she BtAS Batgirl the plucky not quite side kick? Heck, was she Stephanie Brown with red hair and no history as Spoiler? I’m growing tired of DCnU Batgirl’s near constant self questioning. I understand that she’s not at a hundred percent yet and I understand that Gail Simone is laying the basis for the rest of the comic, but the more I read the less I like Babs and the more I want to just quietly go back to finding Oracle’s appearances in trade paperbacks.
This is one of those situations where I want to see what other people have to say about this. I’m going to keep reading for at least the next arc to see how DCnU Babs develops, but I’m thinking that this may not be something that stays on my draw list much longer. What do you think internets? Does the current incarnation make more sense to you that it does me? Where do you think Simone is going to go with Batgirl from here?